Windows 7 Review
Posted 01-06-2009 at 04:35 PM by JDArt
This spring, Microsoft plans to unveil Windows 7 - the successor to Windows Vista - in a public beta program. That means anyone will be able download and try the new operating system - months before it's released. You probably won't want to do this on your main computer - beta software, after all, is bound to have bugs, some of which could prevent you from getting your work done. But if you have an extra computer around, you might want to give the new Windows version a try. Judging from the version of Windows 7 that has already been released to early testers and some members of the press, there's good reason to be hopeful about Windows 7. Here's what's in store.
--- Why Windows 7?
You may not even have upgraded yet to Windows Vista, and already you're hearing about Windows 7. What's the hurry? Apparently, Microsoft has heard enough from its users about Windows Vista - and not much of what they've heard has been good. Adopters of Vista grumble frequently about Vista's frequent interruptions caused by the user account control (UAC) feature, the high system resources required by Vista's Aero interface, general sluggishness, as well as instability and incompatibility with existing software and hardware.
Naturally, word of all of these complaints has gotten around, and adoption rates have been less than expected - especially among corporations. Some customers are even paying hardware makers extra just to install Microsoft's previous operating system - Windows XP - instead of Vista on new machines.
So Microsoft has had plenty of incentive to fix what users don't like about Vista - and fast. Already Windows 7 is becoming known as the operating system that Vista should have been.
--- Installation
The goal of any installation program should be to get your software installed with a minimum of input required. That's especially important for an operating system, which can take 20 minutes or more to be copied to your computer. If you have to supply information to the installation program several times during the process, that's more time wasted - and it means you can't just walk off and return half an hour later, expecting the entire procecure to have completed.
Previous versions of Windows have had terrible installation routines, forcing you to supply information multiple times. Vista improved the situation a bit, but Windows 7 has streamlined installation even further. There are only two times when Windows 7 asks you for input: in the beginning, when you supply your license key and choose the drive on which to install the operating system, and at the end, when you provide a user name and password.
--- Interface
Windows 7's interface is cleaner, more elegant, and faster than Vista's. Gone is the Vista sidebar - the vertical bar to the right that held gadgets. The sidebar was too resource-intensive, Microsoft says, so in Windows 7 your gadgets remain hidden by default but can be activated on the desktop at will.
Libraries are a file organisation concept new in Windows 7. A library looks just like a file folder, but it can actually point to files stored in multiple locations. For example, you can create a library called "files" that points to documents that you have stored in several locations on your C drive as well as several places on your home or corporate network. Double-click the "files" library, and you'll see files aggregated from all of those locations. By default, Windows 7 comes with several libraries pre-defined: Documents, Pictures, Videos, and Music. You can right-click any of those libraries to customise the locations to which they point, and you can create your own libraries with ease.
Windows 7 is full of other small but useful interface enhancements. The Start menu, for instance, doesn't differ greatly in appearance from the one in Vista, but it includes some productivity-boosting features. Icons pointing to recently-used applications now include a fly-out menu that lists recently-opened files within those applications. This means that in Windows 7 you'll have one-click access to the file you were last working on.
The taskbar, too, is graced with some much-needed productivity improvements. First, multiple instances of a minimised application are represented by only one icon on the taskbar. Allow your mouse cursor to hover over that icon, and Windows 7 shows you decently-sized thumbnails of the contents of each instance, making it much easier and quicker than before to return to a particular open file or Web page. Also, a new taskbar button called Show Desktop at the right edge of the taskbar gives you a quick view of what's on the desktop if you allow your mouse cursor to hover over it. Click the button, and all open applications are minised, and you have a full view of your desktop.
--- Performance
You might say that performance is what Windows 7 is all about. Vista has been widely criticised for being too slow - and for slowing users down with annoying user account control (UAC) prompts. By making improvements in performance such a priority, Microsoft has tacitly admitted that it wants to appease disgruntled Vista users.
The company's efforts show. There are far fewer of the annoying UAC prompts that greeted Vista users at almost every turn. And Microsoft has made UAC easier to customise - and to turn off - than it used to be. A new UAC slider allows you to determine exactly which level of UAC protection you want.
Beyond the better-behaved UAC, though, Windows 7 impresses with its overall snappy feel. Windows and dialog boxes appear more responsive, and some features - such as the default view of directory listings, which now favour the "details" view - have been re-engineered with snappiness in mind. Windows 7 also boots quicker and shuts down more speedily than Vista. Several early benchmark reports show Windows 7 already ahead of both Vista and XP in performance on identical equipment.
--- Compatibility
Compatibility issues - both for hardware and software - plagued Windows Vista. The development team at Microsoft wanted to avoid those hassles, as much as possible, for Windows 7, so Microsoft has already published a list of new features which could alter the way that applications run under the new operating system. Essentially most applications designed to run under Windows XP and Vista will work fine under Windows 7. The exceptions include programs that work to enhance the security of Windows - including antivirus software. Already, however, there are at least two vendors that have Windows 7-ready versions of their antivirus products available.
--- Downsides
So what's not to like in Windows 7? The answer to that will depend, in part, on how much you hated the changes that Microsoft introduced in Windows Vista. Vista asked Windows users to do a lot of things differently, and Windows 7 follows suit.
The Windows Explorer file manager in Windows 7, for instance, moves even further away from the familiar tree format used to manage files in XP and previous versions. Some Vista users hate the new Windows Explorer, so for them, a third-party Explorer replacement will probably be in order.
Windows 7 will also, once again, force you to upgrade more applications than you'd like. Your antivirus, anti-spyware, and disk management utilities may no longer work properly with Windows 7. So you'll have to proceed with caution as you install old, familiar programs on the new operating system.
Gotchas aside, the early beta of Windows 7 shows that Microsoft is readying a product that improves in ways that most users want. It's faster, less obtrusive, more customisable, and more attractive than any version of Windows to date.
--- Why Windows 7?
You may not even have upgraded yet to Windows Vista, and already you're hearing about Windows 7. What's the hurry? Apparently, Microsoft has heard enough from its users about Windows Vista - and not much of what they've heard has been good. Adopters of Vista grumble frequently about Vista's frequent interruptions caused by the user account control (UAC) feature, the high system resources required by Vista's Aero interface, general sluggishness, as well as instability and incompatibility with existing software and hardware.
Naturally, word of all of these complaints has gotten around, and adoption rates have been less than expected - especially among corporations. Some customers are even paying hardware makers extra just to install Microsoft's previous operating system - Windows XP - instead of Vista on new machines.
So Microsoft has had plenty of incentive to fix what users don't like about Vista - and fast. Already Windows 7 is becoming known as the operating system that Vista should have been.
--- Installation
The goal of any installation program should be to get your software installed with a minimum of input required. That's especially important for an operating system, which can take 20 minutes or more to be copied to your computer. If you have to supply information to the installation program several times during the process, that's more time wasted - and it means you can't just walk off and return half an hour later, expecting the entire procecure to have completed.
Previous versions of Windows have had terrible installation routines, forcing you to supply information multiple times. Vista improved the situation a bit, but Windows 7 has streamlined installation even further. There are only two times when Windows 7 asks you for input: in the beginning, when you supply your license key and choose the drive on which to install the operating system, and at the end, when you provide a user name and password.
--- Interface
Windows 7's interface is cleaner, more elegant, and faster than Vista's. Gone is the Vista sidebar - the vertical bar to the right that held gadgets. The sidebar was too resource-intensive, Microsoft says, so in Windows 7 your gadgets remain hidden by default but can be activated on the desktop at will.
Libraries are a file organisation concept new in Windows 7. A library looks just like a file folder, but it can actually point to files stored in multiple locations. For example, you can create a library called "files" that points to documents that you have stored in several locations on your C drive as well as several places on your home or corporate network. Double-click the "files" library, and you'll see files aggregated from all of those locations. By default, Windows 7 comes with several libraries pre-defined: Documents, Pictures, Videos, and Music. You can right-click any of those libraries to customise the locations to which they point, and you can create your own libraries with ease.
Windows 7 is full of other small but useful interface enhancements. The Start menu, for instance, doesn't differ greatly in appearance from the one in Vista, but it includes some productivity-boosting features. Icons pointing to recently-used applications now include a fly-out menu that lists recently-opened files within those applications. This means that in Windows 7 you'll have one-click access to the file you were last working on.
The taskbar, too, is graced with some much-needed productivity improvements. First, multiple instances of a minimised application are represented by only one icon on the taskbar. Allow your mouse cursor to hover over that icon, and Windows 7 shows you decently-sized thumbnails of the contents of each instance, making it much easier and quicker than before to return to a particular open file or Web page. Also, a new taskbar button called Show Desktop at the right edge of the taskbar gives you a quick view of what's on the desktop if you allow your mouse cursor to hover over it. Click the button, and all open applications are minised, and you have a full view of your desktop.
--- Performance
You might say that performance is what Windows 7 is all about. Vista has been widely criticised for being too slow - and for slowing users down with annoying user account control (UAC) prompts. By making improvements in performance such a priority, Microsoft has tacitly admitted that it wants to appease disgruntled Vista users.
The company's efforts show. There are far fewer of the annoying UAC prompts that greeted Vista users at almost every turn. And Microsoft has made UAC easier to customise - and to turn off - than it used to be. A new UAC slider allows you to determine exactly which level of UAC protection you want.
Beyond the better-behaved UAC, though, Windows 7 impresses with its overall snappy feel. Windows and dialog boxes appear more responsive, and some features - such as the default view of directory listings, which now favour the "details" view - have been re-engineered with snappiness in mind. Windows 7 also boots quicker and shuts down more speedily than Vista. Several early benchmark reports show Windows 7 already ahead of both Vista and XP in performance on identical equipment.
--- Compatibility
Compatibility issues - both for hardware and software - plagued Windows Vista. The development team at Microsoft wanted to avoid those hassles, as much as possible, for Windows 7, so Microsoft has already published a list of new features which could alter the way that applications run under the new operating system. Essentially most applications designed to run under Windows XP and Vista will work fine under Windows 7. The exceptions include programs that work to enhance the security of Windows - including antivirus software. Already, however, there are at least two vendors that have Windows 7-ready versions of their antivirus products available.
--- Downsides
So what's not to like in Windows 7? The answer to that will depend, in part, on how much you hated the changes that Microsoft introduced in Windows Vista. Vista asked Windows users to do a lot of things differently, and Windows 7 follows suit.
The Windows Explorer file manager in Windows 7, for instance, moves even further away from the familiar tree format used to manage files in XP and previous versions. Some Vista users hate the new Windows Explorer, so for them, a third-party Explorer replacement will probably be in order.
Windows 7 will also, once again, force you to upgrade more applications than you'd like. Your antivirus, anti-spyware, and disk management utilities may no longer work properly with Windows 7. So you'll have to proceed with caution as you install old, familiar programs on the new operating system.
Gotchas aside, the early beta of Windows 7 shows that Microsoft is readying a product that improves in ways that most users want. It's faster, less obtrusive, more customisable, and more attractive than any version of Windows to date.
Total Comments 24
Comments
-
Hi JDArt,
Thanks for the fast and highly readible review, I'm a Vista user and I now very much look for Windows 7 to be released.Posted 01-06-2009 at 11:28 PM by njangka
-
You're quite welcome. The "official" beta release comes out on Friday. MS is allowing only 2.5 million downloads. So get there fast.Posted 01-08-2009 at 04:06 PM by JDArt
-
Sounds interesting - and it's quite refreshing of Microsoft to directly address the issues that plagued Vista.
The one feature that got me excited when Vista was first muted (known as Longhorn in those distant days) was the WinFS file system. This failed to show up in time for the Vista launch. I'm surprised if it's not going to be on Windows 7 either? Maybe they've simply decided it's not worth the effort - which will be a shame as I do think they need to be a bit more radical and progressive in their OS launches...Posted 01-09-2009 at 01:17 PM by Paul Shields
-
>>The one feature that got me excited when Vista was first muted (known as Longhorn in those distant days) was the WinFS file system. <<
LOL. We haven't heard anything about WinFS for a long time, have we?Posted 01-09-2009 at 05:27 PM by JDArt
-
If there's a carpet in Microsoft, it'll have a very large hump where WinFS has been brushed under
.Posted 01-09-2009 at 05:42 PM by Paul Shields
-
I guess WinFS would have broken too many apps.Posted 01-10-2009 at 04:44 AM by JDArt
-
Yes but how does it work when PS is running and you are trying to do real world stuff with big files? That's the info we need and want.Posted 01-14-2009 at 03:17 PM by eric rose
-
Good News...would love to ditch VistaPosted 01-14-2009 at 04:19 PM by PJTN68
-
PS works well under Windows 7. NO issues. In fact it's faster under 7 than under Vista or XP.Posted 01-14-2009 at 04:29 PM by JDArt
-
Good news for us holding on to their older systems with xp..
Thanks for the review J .Was this done on your beta trial ?
I'm intent on hearing any bugs that surface.Posted 01-24-2009 at 05:32 PM by
-
I've heard from other testers that basically there is no advantage over XP. Since XP runs better than Vista then that is an improvement for those users.Posted 01-24-2009 at 05:52 PM by eric rose
-
"I've heard from other testers that basically there is no advantage over XP. Since XP runs better than Vista then that is an improvement for those users."
Well, the trouble is that staying with XP is going to run you into compatibility issues after a while. MS and vendors are dropping support for it.Posted 01-27-2009 at 01:38 PM by JDArt
-
Only two "bugs" I can report from Windows 7:
1) Spyder Pro driver does not get installed under the 64 bit version of Windows 7 because the driver is unsigned. I was able to install it when dring start I hit F8 and disable the signed direvers 'feature'.
2) Apples quicktime causes windows desktop to go into basic mode because its somehow incompatble.
Other than that no issues. I got CS4, LR 2.2, Office 2003, Skype 4, Yahoo, Windows Live Messenger, doPDF Creator, Nero 7 essentials, Opera, Nokia Suite, Norton 360 beta, VMWare 6.5, Rosetta Stone all installed without any problems. This must be the most stable beta I have ever seen. I am running the 64 bit version now as my main OS.
Ever since I switched of the useless indexing engine my system feels like a F1 racing car. Before it was always hanging at cut and paste, deletion or crteating new folders.Posted 02-09-2009 at 10:15 PM by felix.reichardt
-
I've seen more than 2 bugs. One is that my beloved Directory Opus absolutely kills Win7.Quote:Originally Posted by felix.reichardt
Only two "bugs" I can report from Windows 7:
1) Spyder Pro driver does not get installed under the 64 bit version of Windows 7 because the driver is unsigned. I was able to install it when dring start I hit F8 and disable the signed direvers 'feature'.
2) Apples quicktime causes windows desktop to go into basic mode because its somehow incompatble.
Other than that no issues. I got CS4, LR 2.2, Office 2003, Skype 4, Yahoo, Windows Live Messenger, doPDF Creator, Nero 7 essentials, Opera, Nokia Suite, Norton 360 beta, VMWare 6.5, Rosetta Stone all installed without any problems. This must be the most stable beta I have ever seen. I am running the 64 bit version now as my main OS.
Ever since I switched of the useless indexing engine my system feels like a F1 racing car. Before it was always hanging at cut and paste, deletion or crteating new folders.Posted 02-13-2009 at 09:34 AM by JDArt
-
But then I guess that would be a Directory Opus bug and not a Win 7 bug ...
Is Directory Opus something like the Norton Commander was in the good old Dos and early windows times?Posted 02-13-2009 at 07:58 PM by felix.reichardt
-
It's more versatile:Quote:Originally Posted by felix.reichardt
But then I guess that would be a Directory Opus bug and not a Win 7 bug ...
Is Directory Opus something like the Norton Commander was in the good old Dos and early windows times?
GPSoftware Main IndexPosted 02-13-2009 at 08:04 PM by JDArt
-
I'm going to check it ... just downloading ... I kinda miss my good old norton commander ... I can live with what MS gives me but two windows side by side was nice with the Norton Commander.Posted 02-14-2009 at 03:39 AM by felix.reichardt
-
JD, I love that program! I just installed the 64 bit version. It comes up with "your OS is not supported message" but I was still able to install it.
I'm surprised that even the Win 7 libraries work with DO. When are you getting errors? When I installed it it asked me 1000 questions whether I want to replace the standard explorer etc. but I choose not to. Did you go the road for "total replacement'?Posted 02-14-2009 at 04:00 AM by felix.reichardt
-
It completely froze up Windows 7 on me. Twice. Also disabled use of the Control Panel.Quote:Originally Posted by felix.reichardt
JD, I love that program! I just installed the 64 bit version. It comes up with "your OS is not supported message" but I was still able to install it.
I'm surprised that even the Win 7 libraries work with DO. When are you getting errors? When I installed it it asked me 1000 questions whether I want to replace the standard explorer etc. but I choose not to. Did you go the road for "total replacement'?Posted 02-18-2009 at 08:12 PM by JDArt
-
I've been running Win7 64 bit pre-release for several weeks and see no advantage over Vista 32 bit. I also increased memory from 4 gb to 8 gb. The new OS seems to load faster; however, it still falters with the screen content grayed out until it regains itself. I ordered Win7 home edition when MS offered its discount; but I'm not sure I'm really gaining anything with the new program.Posted 09-07-2009 at 11:06 AM by ashforth
Post a Comment
|
Total Trackbacks 0
